Why mentoring matters

We thrive when we matter

We believe that all youth need positive connections to peers and adults, and a community where they belong.

Keith and Deavonie, a mentor and young person in our program, smiling together on a boat trip
Keith & DeavonieMatched for over 7 years
For young people in foster careLong-term, committed relationships make all the difference.

Who are the young people we serve?

Capable young people navigating a system that keeps changing around them.

Young people enter foster care through no fault of their own.

  • Placed in state custody when home isn't safe
  • Often removed from family and community without warning
  • Moved frequently between homes, schools, and communities

The young people we serve are nearly four times as likely to be moved in a given year

General population14%
Young people we serve52%

Youth fall an average of 6 months behind in school with every move.

How placement moves affect youth in foster care

Where the system falls short

Across the country, young people who have been in foster care face steep barriers. These figures reflect gaps in support, not their potential.

1 in 3 experience homelessness each year

Youth in foster care~33%
All young people~4%

69–85% finish high school

Youth in foster care69–85%
All young people95%

71% of young women have been pregnant by age 21

Young women in foster care71%
All young women34%
  • Under 5% earn a college degree

  • 1 in 4 experience post-traumatic stress disorderNearly double the rate among U.S. war veterans

  • 1 in 4 become involved with the criminal justice systemWithin two years of leaving foster care

What's missing?

A caring, consistent adult.

Having a consistent relationship with a supportive adult is crucial for building resilience in young people.

— Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University

For youth in foster care, these relationships are often disrupted by:

  • System involvement. The state decides where they live, and placement shortages can force moves more often than anyone wants.
  • Frequent moves. Each move often means a new home, school, and community, and saying goodbye to most of the people in their life.
  • Relational trauma. After so much loss, trusting someone new can be hard.

Picture 100 young adults who grew up in foster care.

52 didn't have even ONE lasting relationship

48 did, but for most of them, it was just ONE

This lack of connection increases isolation and disrupts healthy development.

CEO Colby Swettberg's TEDx Talk on why consistent, positive relationships matter so much for young people in foster care.

How does a mentor change things?

Consistency builds resilience.

Research on child development shows time and again that consistent, positive relationships are paramount to healthy development.

  • A caring adult helps buffer the impact of trauma and toxic stress
  • Mentoring relationships are best when they're long-term

Studies show that youth with mentors are:

  • 50% more likely to graduate high school

  • 40% more likely to be employed

  • 25% less likely to be in a gang

Longevity is what makes the difference

  • Under 3 monthsRelationships this short can have a negative impact
  • 1 year or moreRelationships lasting at least a year net positive results
  • 4 yearsHow long relationships in our program last, on average

Our theory of change

It starts with
A caring, consistent adultA volunteer mentor who stays, supported by clinically trained staff
Life skillsResource brokeringLeadership opportunities
Which builds
  • Self-efficacyChoosing a path, setting goals and self-advocating
  • Social connectednessPositive relationships and a sense of belonging
  • Positive identitySeeing the value in their own voices
  • Social-emotional skillsExpressing and managing emotions
Which grows
ResilienceThe capacity to cope with adversity and keep moving forward
Which leads to
Healthy interdependence and independence
  • Healthy relationships
  • Mental and physical health
  • Setting and keeping educational goals
  • Economic well-being
Activities Outcomes Impact

Why Silver Lining Mentoring?

A proven track record of impact.

With 25 years of experience, Silver Lining Mentoring is the only mentoring organization in Massachusetts focused exclusively on the unique needs of youth in foster care and is one of the few nationwide with this specialized focus.

Young people's lives are unpredictable and often complicated. Our staff help mentors navigate these challenges so they can persist through inevitable transitions.

Our impact, side by side

How young people in our program compare with their peers nationally.

Over 90% finish high school

Our program90%+
Peers in foster care69–85%

Ages 19 and older. For all young people, it's 95%.

3% experience homelessness

Our program3%
Peers in foster care~33%

For all young people, it's about 4%.

100% had someone to talk to when they needed help

Their mentor was the #1 person they chose.

Rungs of support

What every Silver Lining young person and mentor gets.

A mentor who stays

One volunteer mentor, carefully trained, matched and committed for the long term.

A dedicated program coordinator

A skilled, clinically trained staff member who supports both the young person and the mentor throughout their relationship.

Learn & Earn

Young people earn incentives as they build the financial, career and life skills they need for independence.

Financial assistance

Direct help with emergency needs, from housing and utilities to phone and transportation.

Explore more of our impact in detail

Milestones and national recognition

Over the years, Silver Lining Mentoring has been lauded as a national leader in mentoring services for youth in foster care.

  1. 2014Social InnovatorNamed a Social Innovator through the Social Innovation Forum.
  2. 2015Social Venture Partners investeeChosen as a three-year investee by Social Venture Partners (SVP), whose consultants shared business counsel to help us grow our impact on youth in foster care.
  3. 2017Barr Foundation FellowCEO Colby Swettberg was chosen as a Barr Foundation Fellow, recognizing Colby and Silver Lining Mentoring's impact on the community.
  4. 2019Silver Lining Mentoring InstituteAs mentoring and child welfare organizations nationwide sought our guidance, Silver Lining Mentoring formalized that work by launching its Institute. Today, the Institute has trained and advised organizations in 40 states.
  5. 2024TEDx Boston showcaseOne of only a few nonprofits selected for TEDx Boston's January 2024 nonprofit showcase. Watch the talk.
  6. 2025Representing the U.S. in JapanColby was invited to represent the United States as one of five nonprofit leaders at the inaugural Japan United States Social Innovation Network (JUSSIN) convening, sharing best practices in nonprofit leadership.

Help a young person keep moving forward

Become a mentor with support from our clinically trained staff, or give to help young people build relationships that last.

Sources

  • Moving in a given year: U.S. Census Bureau (2013); Silver Lining Mentoring program data. Six months behind per move: research cited in When Home Keeps Changing.
  • Homelessness and high school completion: Annie E. Casey Foundation; Chapin Hall. College degree: National Foster Youth Institute (2025).
  • PTSD: Casey Family Programs (2005), Northwest Foster Care Alumni Study. Pregnancy by age 21: Greeson et al. (2014), citing the Midwest Evaluation of the Adult Functioning of Former Foster Youth. Justice involvement: National Foster Youth Institute.
  • Consistent relationships and resilience: Center on the Developing Child at Harvard University. Enduring relationships: Okpych et al. (2023).
  • Youth with mentors: DuBois & Silverthorn (2005). Relationship length and outcomes: Grossman & Rhodes (2002). Average relationship length and our program's results: Silver Lining Mentoring program data; see Explore Our Impact.