By Evan Hubbard, LICSW, ACSW, Director of Quality Assurance, Silver Lining Mentoring
Imagine moving 40 miles away, with little notice, to a new place without anyone you know. Now imagine doing that a few times every year throughout your formative childhood and adolescent years. That’s the lived reality for the majority of mentees within Silver Lining Mentoring’s (SLM’s) community.
The mentees we support have an especially strong need for a consistent, stable, positive adult — not only because of the experiences that led to their involvement with the child welfare system, but also because of the high degree of instability they face afterward. Once a young person is in the care of the child welfare system, the state where they live is responsible for finding them the best possible home. But in the face of daunting placement shortages, states are often forced to move youth more frequently than desired.
How SLM Defines a Move
Because SLM’s population faces a high degree of placement upheaval, it can be hard to say what counts as a move versus a temporary or short-term change. For SLM’s purposes, a move is any time a mentee leaves one location and is very unlikely to return within the next six months. For this reason, we don’t count temporary changes, such as a short-term mental health hospitalization, as moves, because the young person will likely return to their most recent residence.
While we don’t count those as moves, it’s important to keep in mind that they are still highly disruptive events that can affect a young person’s employment, education, relationships, and other areas of life.
A Cycle of Constant Change
Each year, about half of our mentees move at least once. And each move increases the likelihood of another, creating a vicious cycle of frequent and repeated disruptions. About 40% of youth who move once will move again that same year — sometimes eight or more times. Most of our matches will navigate about four to eight moves over the course of their relationship.
Complicating things even further, these moves range from a few towns over to more than 100 miles away, with the average distance hovering around 40 miles. In 2025 alone, SLM mentees moved a combined total of about 1,500 miles. Since SLM opened its doors in 2001, mentees have moved a combined total of more than halfway around the world.
What a Move Means for a Young Person in Foster Care
For a young person in foster care, a move is far more than a change of address. It can mean moving to an entirely new region, saying goodbye to most of the people in their life, and adjusting to a brand-new set of house rules and expectations, all while knowing there is a significant chance they will face another upheaval in the not-so-distant future. The repeated disruption can have a cascading impact on nearly every aspect of a young person’s life.
Going the Distance
This is where our work comes in. An SLM mentor is often the only source of stability and consistency for a young person in foster care when their world feels like it’s been turned upside down. And that consistency matters because the effects of a move extend far beyond the immediate disruption. Young people are still working to keep up in school, build relationships, pursue their goals, and prepare for their futures, even as the people, places, and systems around them keep changing.
Research has shown that youth fall an average of six months behind in school with each move. They can also lose important relationships and networks, including teachers, employers, and other adults who know them well and could otherwise serve as a reference or source of support.
That is why, when one of our mentees moves, our team works diligently to locate them, reconnect the match, and coordinate with their new provider team so the mentoring relationship can continue. Our mentors are often quite literally going the distance for their mentee, sometimes traveling three or four hours round trip to maintain that connection. In doing so, they show their mentee that even when circumstances change, some adults can be counted on to keep their promises.
- 3
- years
- 8
- different homes
- 2–3
- moves a year
- 300+
- miles
- 6
- counties
Mentors as History Keepers
Mentors also provide something that is harder to replace: continuity and context. They remember who a young person was before the move, what matters to them, what they have been working toward, and what they may have lost along the way. Ultimately, mentors are history keepers — remembering important milestones, moments, and facts that don’t make it into a case file.
They might bring a favorite meal from a restaurant in their mentee’s old neighborhood when the mentee is missing something familiar, or help a new caregiver understand the emotions behind a behavior. They might notice that their mentee stopped working toward getting a state ID, and discover it was because their birth certificate got lost in the move and they didn’t know how to get a replacement. Other times, it looks like carrying on traditions, like going to the same batting cage and getting ice cream afterward on their birthday, just as they have for every birthday for the last five years.
In these moments, the mentor becomes a bridge between a young person’s past and their future, helping them hold onto important parts of their identity and continue making progress despite circumstances that are constantly changing.
Why Investing in Mentoring Relationships Matters
For young people in foster care, a consistent, committed adult relationship can be the difference between having to start over with every move and having someone who helps them keep moving forward. We often talk about the importance of education, employment, housing, and other building blocks of a successful adulthood. But none of those things exist in a vacuum. Young people need people who know them, believe in them, and remain present long enough to help them navigate the inevitable setbacks and transitions along the way.
It is easy to underestimate the power of a relationship that may look, from the outside, like simply spending time together. But for a young person whose life is defined by constant change, the presence of one dependable adult can be transformative. When we invest in these relationships, we are investing in something fundamental: a young person’s ability to build on what came before, navigate what is happening now, and believe that there is a future worth working toward.

